Affairs and Confronting the Other Woman: Truth Search

Case study of confronting the other woman:

1. What was your purpose for confronting the OP and what did you say/do?

To expose my husband’s lies (he told her that our marriage was over & he was no longer intimate with me) and discover the truth about their affair. Also to to try to convince her to leave my husband and appeal to her that she was damaging our family and hurting my daughter.

2. What happened? What was the outcome?

The other woman was more than happy to share the details of the affair and the lies my husband told her, asked me many questions, and tried to find out why he would lie to her while continuing to tell me he wanted to save our marriage. The affair continued no matter how many times I talked to her over a period of at least 2 years. I believe the affair continues to this day, though my husband and I are now separated.

3. If you were to do it again, would you do it differently? What did you learn?

I don’t know. I learned a great deal about the truth of what had been going on from the other woman, and I wanted the truth but was only getting lies from my husband. However, contacting the other woman did not end the affair in each of the three times that we talked. The other woman is aware that my husband has lied to her since their affair began, but that does not seem to be enough to break her addiction.

Coach’s Comments:

1. Contacting the other person may be a legitimate way to discover the truth that you want. In essence you are setting the other person against your spouse. From that the truth – the extent of the affair, the nature of the relationship, etc – may emerge. It may mean you must read between the lines since personal distortions often exist in infidelity.

2. Sounds like the other woman was very willing to share the details. I wonder what’s with that?? What does that say about her?
The only way to achieve clarity on that would be to pursue a relationship with her. But then, that most likely would be a disaster.

3. Appealing to the goodness of the other person to end the affair is usually a losing proposition. Extramarital affairs and those who engage in them, at that point in their lives, at least, have little regard for what is appropriate or the welfare of others.

Confronting the other Woman: Revenge affair

Another case study: Confronting the other woman when facing a Revenge affair.

1. What was your purpose for confronting the OP and what did you say/do?

The OP had no idea my husband was married. He had told her he was divorced. He travels and she was living in the state he was working in during those months. My motivation was to verify if he had told me the truth about her and their relationship…he hadn’t, he had left out alot and tried to smooth over the details so I wouldn’t know just how involved they were and how much he had betrayed me. His was a revenge affair against me.

2. What happened? What was the outcome?

She was apologetic because she didn’t know, and felt horrible for hurting me unknowingly. And had alot of anger towards him as well. She assured me that if he contacted her in any way she would let me know. She also brought to light some of his lies he kept telling me for the next year AFTER the affair. She contacts me every once and awhile to see how I’m doing and vice versa. We formed an awkward friendship of sorts, trying to repair ourselves. Neither one of us hates the other in any way, and have leaned on each other for emotional support occasionally. She supported me when I decided to stay with my husband and work things out. It’s been a long road.

3. If you were to do it again, would you do it differently? What did you learn?

No I would not do it differently. Especially since he was lying to both of us, I felt responsible to clear the air as to my status with him (yes we were married, i was 9 months pregnant when i found out.) I learned that when the cheating spouse is found out, they want the discovery anger to be brief and the recovery to be quick. And they will deny details to ensure that happens (i.e. i only saw her once a week , when really, he saw her every night, etc.) I learned that I can be the bigger person, and even through the hurt I could forgive the OP in this situation and see the situation for what it was.

Coach’s Comments:

Let’s assume that her assessment is correct; that it is a revenge affair. (Affair type #5 in my E-book, Break Free From the Affair.)

If facing this type of affair, one is confronted with slippery slopes. By that I mean, it’s often very difficult to nail down exactly what is happening. It’s difficult to get a straight answer. One often wonders what the spouse is thinking. And, one picks up on this undercurrent of hostility that says, “leave me alone.”

Some refer to this as “passive aggressive” behavior. The husband was exhibiting the same behavior with the other person – withholding, passively controlling and in essence, limiting intimacy.

Confronting the other person brought clarity and the truth. When the husband was confronted with the truth the gig was up.

Please know that this revenge affair did not slide into a rage affair. Perhaps, over time, if the wife continues confronting the underlying resentment more intimacy might emerge in the marriage.

Infidelity and the Truth: Not in the Emotional Affair

Do you believe that if you confront the other woman, she will tell you the truth?

Hardly, since an affair is built upon deception.

The emotional energy demanded by this type of affair can be intense.

Read this case study and my comments:

1. What was your purpose for confronting the OP and what did you say/do?

To find out how far the emotional affair had gone.

2. What happened? What was the outcome?

She denied communications with my husband, which I already saw from the cell phone charges and knew she was lying. She also blamed him for contacting her and that she was just talking to him to help him work on his marriage. The outcome was my husband was angry with her for blaming him for a friendship she initiated, and she no longer wanted anything to do with him because he was married with a family.

3. If you were to do it again, would you do it differently? What did you learn?

Yes, I would have confronted her the first time she hung up on me when I answered the phone(6 months earlier). I wouldn’t have contacted her – I knew what was going on. I should have separated from my husband and made him face what he was doing without a cushion of being home with his family. I will have less compassion for my husband or the lonely other woman.

Coach’s Comments:

I’m guessing we’re dealing with a form of the “I Fell out of Love… and just love being love” type of affair. This affair revolves around the emotional component.

And, someone involved in an emotional kind of affair is usually (please note, there are exceptions to patterns) a fairly dependent person who focuses his/her life on eliciting from others feedback that will make him/her feel good. Good feelings often come as a result of outside triggers rather than from inside one as they live out their life with purpose, standards and well grounded values.

This person will “play” those people in his/her life to create and guard his/her feelings. Deception is often part of this “playing” since s/he must manipulate his/her world to maintain those “feelings” and keep others away from discovering or her/his disclosing her/his inner emptiness.

Don’t expect the truth here.